Which Composition Do You Prefer?

Thanks, Michael. I just wanted to update people as I had brought this question up awhile back. I had preferred that square crop myself but it just reaffirms the fact that we all look at "art" differently.

As a side note, it seems people with a photography background sometimes look at images differently.  Occasionally an image that didn't do well at our local camera club has gone on to take top honors at the local art guild.